It Turns Out That Giving People What They Want Isn’t The Best Business Model

One of the strange developments in the world of media is the feeling that cultural change and growth has slowed to almost zero.

It’s been a long time since the music industry has seen any big, new sound develop and when it comes to television and movies, while individual projects feel new, audiences are left with this sense that 2026 isn’t all that different than 2016. Or even 2006. Where are the rapid changes and evolutions of taste that used to overwhelm the cultural zeitgeist every few years?

Lauren Leek’s Lauren’s Data Substack has a great piece on why everything is beginning to look the same. And it comes down to algorithms:

❝

Imagine forty options, cuisines, genres, shop types, and a standard algorithm: predict what people want, show them more of it, watch what they pick, update. Then let the loop run.

The mode gets shown more, so it gets picked more, so the model grows more confident the mode is what people want, and the tails starve. Within a few dozen rounds, a catalogue that began almost perfectly even collapses onto one dominant option. But why does it collapse toward the mode rather than fan out across all that individual data?

Almost every recommender is trained to minimise a prediction error, get the rating wrong by as little as possible, or maximise the chance you click. But the problem is that under squared-error loss, the prediction that minimises your expected error is the conditional mean. So an algorithm that is uncertain about you, and it is always at least a little uncertain, hedges toward the average. The more uncertain it is, the harder it pulls you toward the crowd. This is why more data doesn’t save us. Personalisation under a standard loss function is regression to the collective mean with extra steps. Variance, the technical word for the stuff that makes you you, is expensive to predict. Basically, diversity is variance, and optimisers are built to minimise variance.

Netflix executives will tell you they don’t use an algorithm to help them decide which ideas to greenlight. But they (and other streamers) do use algorithms to decide what shows to promote, which indirectly determines which titles receive the attention necessary to get the attention and viewership needed to be successful.

And if you spend enough time on Netflix, you see that play out in real time. The system tends to push what it thinks you want based on past viewing and other factors. But that process strips out the uncertainty that makes us human. And the result is that we end up with shows that feel a lot like other ones we have watched in the past.

Streamers try and bring a human element back into the process by encouraging viewers to like or dislike titles they watch. But that feedback is inconsistent and it’s not clear that it’s even all that helpful.

It’s an ironic time for the television industry, as well as the music labels. The growth of the streaming era has made delivery of new content easier than ever. But that ubiquitous supply has made it even more difficult to create a mass market hit or surface new content the audience might find worthwhile.

Clicking on this ad will provide a bit of extra revenue for TooMuchTV

ChatGPT just recommended your competitor. 

ChatFeatured does the work to get you in the answer instead. Most customers see their first citations inside 7 days.

Is Apple TV Ever Going To Release Jessica Chastain’s Series ‘The Savant’?

The Apple TV drama The Savant was originally scheduled to debut its first two episodes on September 26th, 2025, but just three days before the premiere, the streamer unexpectedly pulled the series.

While there was no official explanation for the move at the time, PR people at Apple suggested to reporters on background that the decision was in response to the murder of conservative media figure Charlie Kirk, who had been killed two weeks previously.

On the face of it, the explanation seemed reasonable, if overly cautious. Especially given the lack of public information about the series. Based on the 2019 Cosmopolitan article “Is It Possible to Stop a Mass Shooting Before It Happens?,” the show starred Jessica Chastain as a woman nicknamed “The Savant,” who was extremely successful at infiltrating online hate groups in order to prevent large-scale public attacks.

Based on a real person, Chastain’s character Jodi Goodwin earned her nickname “The Savant” thanks to her uncanny ability to sense when hate speech would morph into violent action. Goodwin worked secretly for a group based on the the division of the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) that infiltrated online hate groups. The group would identify dangerous individuals, who would then be investigated and often charged with plans to commit shootings, bombings and other mass casualty events. As a producer on the show explained to me, when you see someone arrested just as they are set to follow through with violent threats, this group likely had something to do with it.

When the announcement was made, Chastain posted a long statement on Instagram disagreeing with the move, and at the time, Apple TV told reporters the show would premiere at a later date.

The last update was in September, when a press contact for Apple TV told several of the Hollywood trade outlets the show would premiere “in early 2027.”

In recent days, I’ve attempted to get an update from publicists from the streamer about whether the series is still set to premiere, but have not received an answer.

When I wrote about the delay in February, multiple people suggested to me that Apple TV worried the show would prompt a wave of criticism from conservative media types, who would see the show’s premise as an overt criticism of their political beliefs:

❝

An FBI official who had worked with the ADL’s extremism group for a number of years explained that one of the biggest challenges in their efforts was the insistence of many conservatives that any attempt to reign in potential right-wing violence was somehow an attack on anyone with conservative political beliefs.

This person asked to remain unidentified because they still work in law enforcement: “It was not uncommon for us to arrest someone who was planning a violent act and then hear from critics that they were targeted because of their beliefs. And while that’s the case, it’s not true in the way they mean it.

These people weren’t on our radar because they were conservative. They were under investigation because they were often talking about committing violence, about disrupting the public safety. The truth right now is that while people from any political persuasion are capable of committing a mass casualty event, the majority of them are right-wing zealots.

In the 1960s, the reverse was true. We have to go where the potential crimes might be, not where someone has political beliefs we don’t agree with.”While I don’t agree with Apple’s reasoning, worrying about social media blowback was not an unreasonable concern.

Having watched screeners for the entire season, I didn’t see anything that overtly attacked conservatives, although the protagonist in the season is framed as right-winged. But it’s not done in a way that would criticize an entire swath of American politics.

I honestly don’t know if The Savant will ever premiere. It’s difficult to see it coming out after being delayed 18 months or more. And from a bottom-line standpoint, Apple TV might decide it’s easier just to wrote off the show and move on.

Which would be too bad. Not just because bowing to potential political pressure is a bad thing. But also because The Savant is a really well-made show.

What The Future Holds For The ‘Netflix House’

Last month, I broke the news about layoffs coming at Netflix and discussed some specifics about what I had heard from sources inside the company:

❝

Greg Lombardo, who spearheaded Netflix’s move into retail, including “Netflix House” mall locations in Philadelphia and Dallas, is leaving the streamer after seven years. The departure follows the earlier exit of Pam Levine, VP of marketing and publicity for the U.S. and Canada, after 18 months.

I’m told that while company executives think the move into retail and experiential popups holds promise, the streamer hasn’t cracked the code. And those efforts are nowhere near being worth it when measuring the costs of the experiences or the engagement. I’m told that business is being reworked and sources I’ve spoken to expect some job cuts to come from that division.

And Bloomberg’s Lucas Shaw has a fuller look at those moves in today’s edition of Screentime:

❝

Speaking of experiences… Netflix is reassessing its strategy for its in-person entertainment venues known as Netflix Houses.

The company opened its first two in Dallas and Philadelphia at the end of last year, and is about to open a third in Las Vegas next year. The first two locations were designed as pilots for the initiative, a way for Netflix to learn what worked and didn’t work. The attractions, which feature rotating installations themed to Netflix shows like Stranger Things and Squid Game, charge admission starting at $39.

The initial plan when co-CEO Ted Sarandos and co-founder Reed Hastings approved the initiative was to expand aggressively. They wanted to open dozens of locations all across the US in relatively short order with a focus on more suburban areas with large real estate in malls. (The “Philly” location is really in the King of Prussia suburb while the Dallas location is well north of the city center.)

But the company is pausing any expansion as it digests the initial results from Philly and Dallas, according to people familiar with the company’s plans. The Philly location, the first to open, has been the bigger challenge. It has miniature golf and a theater but less traffic at night. The Dallas location, opened a month later, has been more successful and is now breaking even. It has attracted more large groups and corporate events.

The company has high hopes for the Vegas location, which came about somewhat serendipitously and wasn’t part of the original plan. It could be the model for the future — a smaller venue in an urban center. While the first two are in more suburban locations that rely on repeat visitors, Vegas is a tourist destination with millions of new people every day.

Netflix is also exploring taking the franchise abroad. The next location may look less like Tampa and a lot more like London.

Sarandos and chief marketing officer Marian Lee want to keep investing in experiences that help promote shows (and could make them a little money). They just visited the venue in Dallas for the opening of a KPop Demon Hunters attraction. But they are going to wait a year or so before spending tens of millions of dollars opening another location.

Netflix wants to get into the live experience business. And if the company makes a move for NBCUniversal, one big reason will be Universal’s theme parks division.

But the company hasn’t quite cracked the code yet, and to be fair, no one outside of Disney has quite managed to do it at scale.

Tweet Of The Day

Odds & Sods

  • Variety’s Brian Steinberg is reporting that Willie Geist will exit MS NOW’s Morning Joe after nearly 20 years for an expanded role at NBC's Today.

  • The private detective comedy series Sunset P.I. premieres Monday, February 8th on NBC.

  • Apple TV has renewed Slow Horses for a ninth and tenth season.

  • The Blue Road premieres Friday, November 20th on Netflix. Here is a first look at the trailer. And here is the official logline: “Two detectives from Seoul and Tokyo, played by Son Suk-ku and Eita Nagayama, reluctantly team up to hunt the killer behind a string of gruesome cross-border murders in 2002, as the Korea-Japan World Cup sweeps the region.”

  • I can’t think of anything I want to listen to less than a collection of AI “radio” DJs on Spotify.

  • Warner Bros. TV has signed a new output pact with Skydance sibling AVOD Pluto TV, which will add new FAST channels to the service. Two And A Half Men will be available for the first time on free, ad-supported TV with its own branded channels. That will be joined by channels focused on Veronica Mars, The Jamie Foxx Show, Martin and The Wayan Brothers.

  • Criminal premieres Wednesday, January 17th on Prime Video. Here is a first look at the trailer. And here is the official logline: “Based on Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips’s Eisner Award-winning graphic novels, this crime saga follows childhood friends Leo Patterson (Charlie Hunnam) and Ricky Lawless (Gus Halper). One is trying to escape the criminal world they grew up in, and the other is desperate to follow in his outlaw father’s footsteps.”

The Real Reason Producers Are Fleeing California

The Hollywood Reporter's Steven Zeitchik has a piece about California's film tax credit and how it can't address the primary reason why movies and television shows are shot outside California:

❝

But the real reason expanding the California tax credit ceiling system is the wrong way to think about jumper-cabling the business is that it completely ignores the biggest disadvantage California has.

The state already boasts the most generous tax credit program in the country by many standards — as much as 45 percent for a decent number of productions, compared with a cap of 30 percent in even a rebate-generous state like Georgia. What it lacks compared with Georgia is low prices. The cost of living in Georgia is a full 39 percent lower than California (the most expensive state in the Lower 48), which means housing, feeding and transiting a cast and crew is on a perennial near-half-off sale — the kind of thing some money in possible one-off incentives can’t come close to competing with. Of course, actually addressing affordability is a trickier task than issuing press releases.

The way you know that the real issue doesn’t lie with tax credit ceilings is that the already massive raise to those limits hasn’t seemed to help the problem at all: After the summer 2025 doubling of the ceiling caused a brief spike in production, Los Angeles shoot days are now actually down 23 percent since that time. Not exactly data that makes you say, “Let’s try raising it some more.”

While those are good points, the piece ignores a couple of very substantial other issues.

First, Georgia is having its own production slowdown issues, as it is losing projects to overseas locations, which are substantially cheaper than any state in America can offer.

And secondly, even in the United States, the biggest competitors with California aren’t states such as Georgia and Texas. Production in New York and New Jersey is booming and neither of those states are exactly low-cost.

The premise that film tax credits won’t solve California’s problems is a good one. But this article only managed to talk about a sliver of the real problem.

What’s Coming Tonight And Tomorrow

MONDAY, NOVEMBER 16TH, 2026:
America’s Funniest People Series Premiere (VH1)
Crime And Punishment In America (PBS)
Darius Rucker: They Call Me Hootie (Hulu)
Honest Renovations: A Holiday Home Makeover (The Roku Channel)
Sweet Deceit: Holiday Series Premiere (Food Network)

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17TH, 2026:
Beat Bobby Flay: Holiday Showdown Season Premiere (Food Network)
Death Valley Season Two Premiere (BritBox)
Hells Angels: At War Series Premiere (Vice TV)
He Said, She Said: Till Death Do Us Part Series Premiere (Paramount+)
Mike Ward: Modest (Netflix)
7 Little Johnstons Season Premiere (TLC)
The Circle (Hulu)
The Trio Series Premiere (The Network)
When A Witness Recants (HBO)