There are television dramas that take you into the darkness of the human soul, and then there is The Good Daughter, which seems determined to drag the entire soul down into a Georgia swamp, bury it under a pile of family secrets and come back the following morning to make sure it is still suffering. Peacock's new six-part thriller has so much misery packed into its running time that you half expect the screen to start sweating blood. If this is what happens when a family gets together for Thanksgiving, somebody should call the National Guard.

Based on Karin Slaughter's 2017 novel, and adapted for television by Slaughter herself, The Good Daughter is a Southern Gothic crime drama about two sisters whose childhood was destroyed by a home invasion that left their mother dead and their family permanently fractured. Twenty years later, the sisters are still carrying the wreckage around like a couple of people who have been told that emotional baggage is now considered acceptable checked luggage.

Rose Byrne plays Samantha Quinn, the older sister, now a wealthy New York patent attorney whose polished exterior suggests that she has spent two decades trying to turn herself into somebody who never has to look backward. Meghann Fahy plays Charlotte, or Charlie, the younger sister, who stayed in Pikeville, Georgia, and followed their father into the criminal-defense business. Charlie is the family member who never quite escaped the blast radius. Sam got out. Charlie stayed behind to deal with the smoke.

Then Daddy gets stabbed.

Daddy, in this instance, is Rusty Quinn, played by Brendan Gleeson, a disheveled, whiskey-soaked defense attorney whose approach to life seems to involve quoting literature, dispensing questionable wisdom and occasionally putting on a red clown nose. He is a walking contradiction, a man whose courtroom instincts may be sharper than his personal judgment. Gleeson plays him with the magnificent battered dignity of somebody who has spent a lifetime getting punched by fate and has finally decided to punch back with a joke.

Rusty's stabbing brings Samantha home, where she must confront the sister she left behind and the past she has spent years trying to bury. Meanwhile, Charlie finds herself caught up in a high-school shooting case involving an 18-year-old girl accused of killing a coach and another student. The case becomes tangled in the Quinn family's history, and before long the series is throwing enough revelations around to make a filing cabinet explode.

There is also the matter of the original home invasion, the masked intruders and the terrible things that happened to the girls after they were taken into the woods. The show keeps circling back to this event, peeling away another layer of horror whenever it needs to remind us that nobody in Pikeville has enjoyed a decent night's sleep since the Clinton administration.

The question is whether all this darkness amounts to anything beyond an elaborate exercise in emotional punishment.

Well, sometimes it does. And sometimes it feels as though Slaughter has decided that if one terrible thing happens to a character, the appropriate response is to send in three more terrible things wearing little name tags.

The series has a serious problem with trauma inflation. Every time you think the story has reached its quota of human suffering, another buried secret surfaces. The characters are practically walking crime scenes. There are so many flashbacks and revelations that the viewer begins to feel less like an audience member and more like an unpaid investigator who has been assigned an impossible case by a sheriff with a drinking problem.

This is particularly frustrating because the central relationship between Sam and Charlie is genuinely compelling. The two sisters have become radically different people, but the old family dynamics remain embedded in their behavior. Their conversations have the combustible quality of people who know precisely where the other person's emotional land mines are buried because they helped plant them.

Fahy is especially good as Charlie, a woman whose toughness often disguises an almost desperate need to keep the remaining pieces of her family together. She has the sort of chaotic energy that suggests somebody who might burst into tears while simultaneously telling you exactly where you can shove your sympathy. Her performance gives the series much of its emotional credibility.

Byrne, meanwhile, plays Sam as a woman who has constructed an entire identity around leaving her past behind. She is stylish, controlled and professionally successful, with a wardrobe that seems to have been assembled by a committee of extremely expensive funeral directors. Her relationship with Charlie is prickly from the beginning, but Byrne gradually exposes the hurt beneath the armor. There is real chemistry between the actresses, and whenever they share a scene, the show suddenly remembers that it is supposed to be about human beings rather than a collection of increasingly gruesome plot developments.

Their scenes together have a particularly nasty, funny sibling rhythm. They can communicate affection through an insult and express resentment through a perfectly timed silence. It is the sort of relationship that makes you understand why family reunions sometimes require both a therapist and a getaway car.

And then there is Gleeson, who is having an absolute ball playing Rusty, even when the character is clearly having a terrible time. He gives the series a badly needed center of gravity. Rusty is a man with a complicated relationship to morality, a father who loves his daughters but has managed to make their lives considerably more difficult through his own decisions. His clown nose is practically a philosophical statement. Life is a joke, the joke is on you, and the only sensible response is to keep talking.

Gleeson makes this damaged old lawyer considerably more interesting than the screenplay sometimes allows him to be. His scenes with Fahy and Byrne provide the show's most satisfying emotional moments, particularly when the family dynamic slips out from beneath the crime plot. There is a strange tenderness to Rusty, a man who seems to understand that he has failed his daughters in ways that cannot be repaired by a clever quotation or a fresh bottle of bourbon.

The supporting cast is solid, too. Olivia Williams brings emotional weight to the family's history as the girls' mother, while Harper Steele is underused as Lenore, Rusty's longtime assistant and confidante. Michael Dorman plays Charlie's estranged husband, Ben, whose relationship with her has enough unresolved complications to fuel another six episodes. Jake McDorman and Shayna Bernardo contribute to the increasingly tangled high-school shooting storyline.

But the real problem is that The Good Daughter keeps getting distracted by its own machinery.

The mystery is constructed with the sort of elaborate plotting that has become almost mandatory for streaming thrillers. Everybody has a secret. Every family has a history. Every seemingly minor character may turn out to be carrying some enormous piece of information that will rearrange the entire narrative. The series wants to keep you guessing, but there are stretches when it feels less like suspense and more like watching somebody repeatedly shuffle a deck of cards.

The small town of Pikeville should be another character in this drama, a place where old grudges and generations of resentment have created a particularly toxic atmosphere. Instead, it sometimes feels like a generic Southern television backdrop populated by suspicious locals and people who appear to have been born knowing something terrible about the Quinn family. The novel apparently has considerably more texture in its depiction of the community, its prejudices and the social machinery that keeps the characters trapped. The television adaptation occasionally reduces that complexity to a collection of convenient villains and suspicious neighbors.

There is also something worth considering about the series' treatment of violence against women. Slaughter has built a career exploring the ways violence reverberates through the lives of women, and her decision to adapt her own novel gives the production an intimate connection to that material. The series is interested in survivor's guilt, the unequal distribution of power and the way communities can turn their own victims into objects of suspicion. Those are worthwhile subjects. The problem is that the show sometimes mistakes the accumulation of terrible experiences for a deeper understanding of what those experiences do to people.

It is possible to make a devastating drama without making every episode feel like an emergency room waiting area.

Still, there is enough here to keep the whole operation from sinking into the swamp. Steph Green, whose previous work includes The Americans and Watchmen, knows how to handle tension and understands that a close-up of a troubled face can sometimes accomplish more than another elaborate flashback. The production has a convincing Southern atmosphere, and the six-episode format gives the story enough room to develop, even if it occasionally feels as though the writers are trying to squeeze an entire filing cabinet of bad memories into every hour.

The series also benefits from a certain willingness to embrace its own grotesquerie. Rusty's clown nose, his eccentric courtroom behavior and his relationship with his daughters provide moments of dark comedy that are welcome precisely because the surrounding material is so relentlessly grim. Without Gleeson, the show might be in danger of becoming an endurance test disguised as prestige television.

And what of the title? Who exactly is the good daughter? Is it Charlie, who remained in Pikeville and devoted herself to her father? Is it Sam, who escaped and built a life far removed from the family disaster? Or is the entire question a trap, another way of forcing women to define themselves through the expectations of a family that has already taken far too much from them?

That is the most interesting question the series raises, and one it doesn't always give itself enough time to explore. The idea that family loyalty can become a kind of imprisonment is considerably more fascinating than the latest revelation about who did what to whom in the woods twenty years ago.

Ultimately, The Good Daughter is a good deal better when it stops trying to be the cleverest mystery in the room and lets its actors deal with the emotional wreckage. Byrne and Fahy make the sisterly relationship feel lived-in and complicated. Gleeson gives the whole production a bruised, unpredictable humanity. The rest is a rather overstuffed Southern Gothic contraption that occasionally mistakes the sound of breaking glass for profound insight.

You may find yourself pressing the button for the next episode, even as you wonder whether anybody in Pikeville has ever considered moving somewhere else. Preferably somewhere without a history of murder, a suspicious sheriff or a family lawyer who owns a clown nose.

There is a terrific drama lurking inside The Good Daughter. It just needs to stop digging up the bodies long enough to let us meet the living.