There is something almost perversely fascinating about watching a television production with the financial resources of a small nation repeatedly trip over its own beard. Three seasons in, The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power has become a kind of monument to the proposition that money cannot buy imagination, that spectacle is not the same thing as grandeur, and that you can put a thousand people in chain mail, give them swords, horses, dragons, magic rings and enough digital lava to boil the oceans, and still wind up with something that has all the spiritual vitality of a corporate retreat in a haunted shopping mall.

This is not merely a problem of Tolkien purism, although the purists have plenty to complain about. It is a problem of dramatic life. The show keeps assembling the furniture of myth without understanding what makes anybody want to live in the house. There are kingdoms, betrayals, ancient evils, forbidden attractions, dynastic crises, prophecies and supernatural visitations. Everybody is either brooding, conspiring, explaining something portentous or staring into the middle distance as if they've just received a particularly distressing quarterly earnings report. The machinery is elaborate. The pulse is weak.

Season Three arrives with the promise of a course correction, a fresh start, a sort of narrative spring cleaning. And, to its credit, it does appear to have learned a few things from the previous two seasons. The Harfoots have largely disappeared, sparing us another extended excursion into the adventures of people who seem to have wandered in from a different, considerably less interesting television program. The story has moved toward the great historical collisions that should give this material its thunder. Sauron is consolidating his power, the rings are becoming instruments of domination, Númenor is edging toward catastrophe, and the various peoples of Middle-earth are beginning to understand that their problems are not going to be solved by having another solemn meeting.

But the show still has the peculiar habit of taking a perfectly serviceable dramatic situation and smothering it beneath several tons of decorative nonsense.

The central improvement is that the season has finally stopped treating mystery as a substitute for storytelling. We know who Sauron is. We know what he wants. We know that the rings are not particularly good for anybody's long-term mental health. The question is no longer whether the Stranger is Gandalf or whether some shadowy character is secretly somebody else from the family album of Middle-earth. The question is what these people are going to do now that the machinery of evil is actually in motion.

Charlie Vickers remains the show's most valuable asset. His Sauron has a quality that the rest of the production could desperately use: an actual personality. He is vain, manipulative, theatrical, needy, and occasionally almost pathetic, which is precisely what makes him interesting. Evil is more compelling when it has a recognizable human face, even if that face belongs to an immortal supernatural tyrant with an unfortunate enthusiasm for black leather accessories. Vickers understands that Sauron is not simply a walking special effect with a sinister voice. He is a creature of appetite and resentment, a cosmic control freak who cannot tolerate the possibility that anybody might have an independent thought.

Unfortunately, the show seems determined to surround this genuinely interesting performance with a supporting cast of people who have been ordered to speak exclusively in capital letters. The dialogue continues to suffer from that peculiar fantasy affliction in which nobody can simply say they're angry, frightened, in love or having a bad afternoon. They must instead invoke the burden of ages, the shadow of destiny, the sorrow of the fallen, the lamentation of the stars, and approximately seventeen other abstractions before getting around to the point. It is as if every conversation has been translated from English into a language spoken exclusively by funeral directors.

The show's most promising new development is Marnûkh, an orc who breaks with Sauron and becomes an uneasy companion to Galadriel and Arondir. This is the sort of creative gamble that could have been genuinely exciting if the series had the nerve to let it become something strange and unpredictable. The character brings a welcome injection of humor and personality into an otherwise oppressively solemn universe. His relationship with the two elves supplies some of the season's livelier moments, although the resemblance to the Frodo-Sam-Gollum dynamic is impossible to miss. Still, an imperfect new character with a pulse is preferable to another perfectly coiffed elf explaining the metaphysical implications of a mysterious piece of jewelry.

Galadriel, meanwhile, remains caught between the demands of being a legendary warrior, a political figure, a tragic romantic heroine and the person who apparently must personally attend every inconvenient development in Middle-earth. Morfydd Clark has the intensity to carry the character, but the writing keeps confusing emotional complexity with romantic indecision. The arrival of Celeborn, played by Jamie Campbell Bower, brings a new dimension to her history, but the suggestion of a lingering emotional entanglement with Sauron threatens to turn one of Tolkien's most formidable figures into the central character in a supernatural daytime soap opera. Somewhere, a thousand-year-old elf is asking for the manager.

The dwarf storyline is another case of a potentially terrific idea being dragged into the swamp of television melodrama. Khazad-dûm, with its subterranean magnificence and the gathering threat beneath its foundations, ought to be one of the season's great attractions. Instead, the arrival of additional royal relatives and the complications surrounding the Seven Rings threaten to turn the whole business into a particularly expensive episode of Dynasty, with beards. Owain Arthur and Sophia Nomvete continue to bring warmth and conviction to Durin and Disa, but even good actors can only do so much when the script keeps handing them increasingly ridiculous family business.

Númenor is scarcely better. Here we have a civilization that should represent the terrifying apex of human achievement, a kingdom whose greatness contains the seeds of its own destruction. Its story should be Shakespearean, or at least something approaching the magnificent political and psychological tragedy that Tolkien intended. Instead, the political maneuvering feels strangely small. Ar-Pharazôn lacks the dangerous grandeur of a man whose ambition will eventually bring an entire civilization crashing into the sea. The conflict between the Faithful and their opponents is there, but the emotional and historical weight hasn't quite arrived. It's like watching a production of King Lear in which everybody is arguing over who gets the parking space.

And then there's Gandalf, still wandering around with Tom Bombadil, a character who seems to have been imported from an entirely different dimension of television. Daniel Weyman has settled into the role, and Rory Kinnear brings an agreeable eccentricity to Bombadil, but the storyline remains an awkward mixture of cosmic exposition, whimsical business and occasionally baffling slapstick. At one point the season seems to confuse magical revelation with the sort of thing that happens when somebody accidentally sits on a whoopee cushion. There are mysteries here, certainly, but not all mysteries are worth solving, and not every beloved Tolkien character needs to be dragged into the middle of a plot simply because the production has acquired the rights to put him on screen.

The visual side remains the show's great defense attorney. Middle-earth is frequently gorgeous. The mountains, forests, underground kingdoms and vast battlefields have the kind of scale that makes you want to climb into the television and stay there until the next commercial break. The orc design is particularly effective, and the production can still produce moments of genuine visual poetry. But beauty has become something of a trap. The series looks so expensive that its deficiencies become almost insulting. Every time the camera sweeps across another monumental landscape, you find yourself wondering whether the writers were allowed to see it before they started typing.

Bear McCreary's score does its job, sometimes quite beautifully, but the music too often announces the emotional significance of a scene rather than discovering it. The production has a tendency to tell us that something is profound instead of allowing the actors and the material to make it profound. This is the difference between genuine grandeur and the appearance of grandeur, a distinction that seems to have escaped an awful lot of people with very large budgets.

And that's ultimately the maddening thing about The Rings of Power. It is not an irredeemable catastrophe. It is something much more frustrating: a show that periodically demonstrates exactly how good it could be, then wanders off and spends forty minutes doing something else. It has actors who understand the material, production designers who can conjure an entire civilization out of wood, stone and pixels, and a literary universe whose imaginative possibilities are practically inexhaustible. Yet it keeps mistaking the accumulation of material for the creation of drama.

The problem with Tolkien is that his world is not simply a collection of names, genealogies, magical objects and historical events. It is a moral universe. His stories are about the corruption of good intentions, the seduction of power, the endurance of friendship, the terrible cost of pride and the stubborn survival of hope. The rings matter because of what they reveal about the people who desire them. Sauron matters because he represents something more frightening than an army of monsters: the belief that everything and everyone can be made to serve a single will.

The television series occasionally understands this. Vickers's Sauron is proof of it. The relationship between Durin and Elrond, in its better moments, is proof of it. Marnûkh's unexpected humanity suggests that there are still interesting corners of this world waiting to be explored. But the series too frequently buries its own best instincts beneath exposition, romantic complications and the desperate need to make every scene sound like the final paragraph of an ancient prophecy.

There is a peculiar irony in spending this much money to recreate a world whose greatest heroes repeatedly discover that the most important things cannot be bought, commanded or conquered. Amazon has constructed a magnificent machine for telling a story about the dangers of power, and the machine itself seems incapable of understanding the lesson.

Season Three is better. Sometimes considerably better. It has more momentum, a more interesting Sauron, some worthwhile new characters and enough spectacular filmmaking to remind us why returning to Middle-earth remains such an irresistible proposition. But it is still a frustratingly uneven enterprise, forever hovering between the possibility of greatness and the reality of an overstuffed fantasy soap opera.

I want to love this thing. I want it to get its filthy hands around my throat and drag me into the dark forests of Middle-earth. I want to feel the dread of Sauron's rising power, the tragedy of Númenor, the splendor of the Elves and the terrible weight of history moving toward its inevitable catastrophe. Instead, I frequently feel as though I'm watching an extremely expensive rehearsal for a show that hasn't quite figured out what it wants to be.

Three seasons in, the question isn't whether The Rings of Power can afford to look like Middle-earth. It can. The question is whether it can finally learn to feel like Middle-earth.

The answer, so far, is occasionally. And occasionally, when you're talking about Tolkien, is a pretty miserable place to set up camp.