From the MMA cage to the kitchen, Ben Neumann has never been afraid of a little competition. The Minnesota baker, who turned a garage into a commercial bakery and eventually made baking his full-time career, is now taking his skills to a national audience as a contestant on Fox's new series Next Level Baker.

Neumann's path to baking success wasn't exactly conventional. An analytical thinker who once focused on martial arts as both a fighter and instructor, he discovered a passion for baking while experimenting with homemade health foods. A less-than-successful attempt at a church potluck eventually led to a three-tier chocolate cake that won over the crowd—and sparked a new obsession.

Since then, Neumann has built a business specializing in pies and ice cream, balancing the demands of entrepreneurship with family life. Now he's putting his baking abilities to the test in a competition that requires not only technical skill and preparation but also the ability to adapt when unexpected challenges arise.

When I recently spoke with Neumann, discussed his unconventional journey into baking, how his MMA and military experiences prepared him for the pressures of reality television, the challenges of building a business from scratch, and what viewers can expect when Next Level Baker premieres on Fox.

The interview has been lightly edited for clarity:

Rick Ellis: Ben, I was reading that you started baking when you were about 21, and I'm curious about that because baking is a very specific skill set. There's a lot of precision. It's not the type of thing that someone typically decides, "Hey, I think I want to bake."

Ben Neumann: Yeah, well, I've always had a little bit more of an analytical mind, so baking comes more naturally to me than cooking. My wife does all the cooking for the house, and I do most of the more fine-tuned baking things.

Basically, I got into fighting right around that time, and at first, I was getting really into health food and making everything from scratch. There was no sugar or flour in my house. It was really hardcore health food for a while.

Then, to give you the shorter version of the story, I got into a potluck at our church and tried making some health-hippie-type bars. They didn't go over well. So I came back thinking, "Well, I'm going to try something else." I'd been watching some of the baking shows. The cake shows were big at the time, so I decided to make a three-tier chocolate forest cake and bring that in.

Everyone just ate it up. My mind was like, "Yeah, take that, other grandmas at church! They ate my food this time!" I kind of liked the competitiveness of it. I liked being able to really analyze and fine-tune the recipes over time. I started baking bread from scratch, and it kind of took off from there.

Well, you also do MMA, and I understand you're an instructor now. What do those two things have in common? You talk about the analytics and figuring things out, but are there some things that helped you in both baking and MMA?

Ben Neumann: Oh, yeah. You know, with fighting, a lot of people are more like cooks than bakers. A lot of people fight more on instinct and emotion, and I was the opposite. I was very analytical and not emotional about it at all.

It was more about asking, "How can I strategize and use my technique to overpower or beat this opponent?" You make a specific strategy for each opponent, train your techniques, and have confidence in what you've practiced over time. That was how I approached fighting.

That helped me dial in different areas of my life where I needed to have success: mental strength, preparation, dedication, strength and conditioning, and diet. There are a lot of aspects that go into fighting, and I think being a little more analytical helped with my approach.

Contestants Ben, Marlina, and Courtney
(Lorraine O’Sullivan / FOX. ©2026 FOX Media LLC.)

Having that fighting experience and military experience, did that make it a little bit easier to deal with the pressure of the show? Because it's intense, no matter who you are, and that's part of the trick of doing well in shows like that: having the ability to deal with the stress and the unexpected twists and turns.

Ben Neumann: Yeah, I think it did. It was interesting watching the other contestants throughout the show and seeing how they were handling it. In my mind, I've been through some things. Don't get me wrong, like I said, it is a stressful competition, but it's different. The stakes are lower in many ways.

It's a great grand prize, and it's huge publicity for my bakery if I win. But I'm not going to get knocked out in front of everyone, basically in my underwear, like when I'm fighting MMA. And I'm not going to get killed like when I was in Iraq, even though I had a safer job over there.

Still, it's something I thought about at the time. Something might happen. A mortar could land in my office building tomorrow.

So, yeah, the stakes are different.

What was your biggest fear going into this? You said you'd seen a lot of these shows in the past. What was your biggest fear about participating in the show?

Ben Neumann: You know, I spoke about it with my wife. We talk everything over. This was a big decision, trying to get on the show and participate in the competition.

We were thinking, what's the worst-case scenario? Let's say you get eliminated first and look like an idiot. Gordon Ramsey makes fun of you. Is anyone going to stop going to your bakery because of that? Probably not. If anything, people will come as a joke, buy something, and post it online. You'll make a sale out of it.

So I'm thinking, what's the downside? I've looked like an idiot in public before. This might not be the first time!

Well, that's actually a good advertising slogan. You know, “Buy a pie from the guy Gordon Ramsay called this guy an idiot!”

I’ll take it.

You started doing this in your garage, which you converted into a commercial bakery. It sounds like, from what I've read, that a lot of this was something you were figuring out as you went along. You weren't quite sure where this was headed or how it was going to work out.

Ben Neumann: Yeah, it seems like a lot of areas of my life start out as a hobby, and then all of a sudden, I'm doing them full-time or for money.

Fighting was just a hobby at first, and eventually I became a full-time instructor and MMA fighter. Baking started as a hobby while I was fighting. I renovated my garage into a bakery in 2017, and I continued fighting and teaching for another four years or so after that.

In 2021, I stopped teaching full-time and fighting, and now I'm just doing the bakery full-time. It was originally just going to be a hobby.

I thought maybe I could pay off the renovation over five years by selling pies for fun during the holidays. Eventually, it made sense for our family for me to switch to doing it full-time so I could be in charge of my hours. Now that we have two little ones in the house, we can be home with our kids all day and always have Mom or Dad watching them.

Do you remember that moment when you realized, "This is going to work. This is actually going to be my career"?

Ben Neumann: Yeah, it was during COVID. You have more time to think when you're home a lot. For a while, we couldn't have classes or teach martial arts every day, so that's usually what kept my mind busy.

I was thinking about how we had already signed up, or were in the process of signing up, for foster care. With foster care, you could get a baby with as little as 24 hours notice. I was thinking, how are we going to watch the baby if my wife's at work and I'm at work at the same time?

My wife is a server, and she works nights. I was teaching every night, too. So I thought, maybe if I quit my job, we'll always have someone home to watch the kids.

I started crunching the numbers, and over a few months, I thought, "I think it's kind of risky, but not too risky. I think we can make it if I just go hard at it."

So, yep, we made the decision, and we're getting there.

Now, in theory, I have a son, and it's one of those things where you think, "Okay, look, I can arrange the schedule. It's going to be okay. It's not going to be a problem." What were the things that popped up that you didn't think about going into this? Were there scheduling issues or just anything else?

Ben Neumann: You don't really understand the number of hours it takes to start a business from scratch until you start doing it.

You think, "Oh yeah, I can make all the pies. It only takes this amount of time." But what about building a website from scratch because you don't have the money to pay someone? What about marketing all the new recipes and trying to get advertising going?

There are just so many facets to running a business. That's kind of what keeps it interesting. There's always something new to learn or do, but all of a sudden, all your time is gone.

Trying to scale it up and hire employees is a big process. Maybe I should reach out and talk to more people, but I just figure things out on my own, read online, and wing it. There are probably more efficient ways to do things if I knew five other entrepreneurs to talk to, but I'm just making it up as I go along, and so far, it's working.

Maybe next year, especially if I win this competition, we can afford to purchase a building and get out of the house. That would be nice.

You make, among other things, gluten-free pies, which I'm a big fan of. My wife and son are both gluten-free, so I've got to check this out now.

Ben Neumann: Yeah, yeah, drop on by! Basically, we're open every day from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. We're in a residential area, but we have normal business hours, and we always have 30 or 40 flavors of pie available.

You can even order delivery from us. We deliver all the way up to St. Cloud, all the way down to Rochester, and throughout the Twin Cities area. Just go to benthebaker.com, and you can see everything there.

We'll be opening up our Thanksgiving preorders soon. Thanksgiving is like the Super Bowl of the year for us. That's pie season. I call it that because we're coming up on pie season here!

My favorite time of the year!

I want to talk a little bit about the show. Like I said at the beginning, I'm not going to ask specific questions about how you did or anything that might involve spoilers. But I'm curious: You knew what you were getting into to a certain extent, so what preparation did you do going into this? Whether it was trying to learn some new skills or hone some things, how close was that preparation to what you actually had to deal with?

Ben Neumann: That's interesting. Yeah, I definitely had to broaden my skills and brush up on a lot of things because we just do pie and ice cream here. We specialize in those two things.

I used to make cakes and do weddings, not a lot of them, but I've done a few. I've also made bread on my own, and I've done a lot of these other things as a hobby. I just enjoy doing it.

But, to be honest, I haven't baked bread in several years. I think I made a cake for my daughter's first birthday, but apart from that, I hadn't made a cake in seven or eight years.

So basically, we were looking through different categories of things and asking, what could they possibly throw at you? Let's work on some recipes.

Even the crew at Next Level Baker sent us some ideas of things we might want to make sure we'd brushed up on. They gave us the general categories: Make sure you've brushed up on cakes, maybe éclairs or other pastries.

I was working my way through all of that. Our bakery kitchen was being used, so I had to use the house kitchen again. With two toddlers and stuff everywhere, I was up until 2 a.m. a lot of nights making extra cakes.

I still had to run the bakery while preparing for this competition, so it was pretty busy and wild for a few weeks.

It definitely helped me. I think there were a lot of times during the competition when I thought, "I'm sure glad I practiced this. I'm sure glad I wasn't just winging it coming in."

That said, this isn't the kind of competition you can fully prepare for because you have random ingredients coming down, you don't know what kitchen you're going to be in or which level, and you might have the best equipment or just garbage-level equipment down in the basement.

You really can't prepare for everything, and that's probably why it's such an interesting competition to watch. It's hard to adapt on the fly, and that's kind of the fun of watching these shows. It's fun to watch people struggle, I think. So you might get to see me struggle a little bit!

You mentioned that you had these discussions with your wife. I'm curious: What was her reaction when you got back home after all this? I'm guessing it was, "Here's the kids. I need a break now!"

Ben Neumann: I had to pare back a little bit. I got to spend some extra time with my kids over the next week or two.

It was great. We have a lot of family in the area who were able to come help and take a day here or an afternoon there, so my wife wasn't totally overwhelmed.

But, yeah, she did a lot. Running the whole house for almost two weeks without me being around to help at all is not easy.

It's great having a great wife who's on the same page as you, where you see things eye to eye and make it work.

Now, are you going to be watching these episodes with friends and family? How's that going to work? Because obviously you know how it's going to go, but win or lose each episode, are you going to have people there, or do you just want it to be you and your wife chilling?

Ben Neumann: We're going to do a small get-together with family. My parents and my wife's parents, along with some of my family who live in the Twin Cities, are going to drive over, at least for opening night.

I think my wife's going to make dinner for everyone, so everyone can get here around 6 p.m., have dinner together, hang out, and watch when it comes on. It's going to be at 8 p.m. on Fox, so everyone's got to tune in!

That's Thursday, November 19, the week before Thanksgiving, and every Thursday after that. If you miss it, you can catch it on Hulu the next day.

I think we'll have a watch party with the family for the first episode. Maybe we'll Zoom in with family members who can't make it so I can explain some behind-the-scenes stuff. That might be fun.

After the first episode, maybe we'll just keep it low-key. We'll get back to the kids' routine and work the next day and all that.

But it'll be a fun opening episode, at least, I think.

Next Level Baker airs Thursdays nights 9:00 p.m. ET/PT on Fox.